451 smart fortwo

Is anyone else having these problems?

Tires - I recently had to replace my front tires at 20,000 miles due to cupping and excess wear on the inside. I had a four wheel alignnment performed ($99.95!?) which showed the front end only slightly out on one side, not nearly enough to have caused the wear. Could this be a design or specification problem?

Roof - The plastic roof panel has developed a "checking" problem all over. These are little cracks throughout the panel that weren't there for the first 18 months I owned the car. My smart Service Center said "They all do that." That may well be but could just mean they all have the same defect! Anybody had their roof replaced for a similar problem?

I'd appreciate hearing from others regarding their experience with these issues.

Thanks

Dave Strom - South Boston, VA

Tags: alignment, checking, defects, roof, tires

Comment

You need to be a member of 451 smart fortwo to add comments!

Join 451 smart fortwo

Comment by Oneoftheguyz on November 26, 2010 at 3:09pm
Believe it or not, front tire wear can be improved by changing the rear springs! I have a car with new rear springs I originally put in for better handling and less body roll in the corners. before the spring change, I had similar wear issues with the front tires. An unexpected added benefit of the spring change is reduced understeer (Push), which reduces the side wear on the front tires, and makes the steering lighter as well. The car now has over 60K Miles with much better wear and ride. I recently changed wheels and tires to a very different aspect ratio, but the difference was evident with the alloy wheels and original equipment tires. Here's a tech link: http://www.3guyz.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=64&Itemid=118
Robert  Ricewasser Comment by Robert Ricewasser on November 26, 2010 at 5:36am
Go over to www.smartcarofamerica.com and research the roof crazing issue. From what I have read, smart has a new replacement roof from a different supplier. Make sure you get the updated roof as a replacement. I live in Southern California and so far my panoramic roof has not had any issues.
Comment by Michael Everett on November 25, 2010 at 11:56pm
The Continnental brand tires have a bad wear rating. They are soft tires. My rear tires picked up a ton of nails and screws. I switched to Kumho tires. They have more pressure in them and give a stiffer ride but no repairs after 10,000 miles. Will switch the fronts soon, and will brand shop them as well. My roof has developed some checks as well?
Tony Comment by Tony on April 10, 2010 at 9:07pm
Hi Dave. I've had no issues with my tires, I did a swap to "all same size" early part of September 2009 ahead of the outSmart the Dragon event. The car handles much better now with all 15" front now the same as the back is stock. I think with about 23,000 miles I will be replacing my rear tires in about 5 or 6000 miles. I think by the end of 2010.

As for the roof. The roof is made of a polycarbonate material. It seems that in some of the excessively hot climates such as Florida Texas and Southern Cali, this issue showed up first. I had my roof replaced I believe mid October 2009 due to the spider cracking, crackling, hazing, ... so many names. Basically it cracked up but didn't break. smart replaced it under warranty. I was told that if I had to pay for it, the cost would have been over a grand. Wow. They gave no clear reason why it did what did, but did not give me any issue with replacing it.
Comment by Bum-Bling-B on March 11, 2010 at 10:05pm
I've had two roofs replaced on 2 of my smarts. At first the dealer was surprised to hear of something but it is now beginning to be a common problem so they are a bit more used to it.

Members

  • urban wheeler
  • mr bad example
  • Smartuki
  • koya konan
  • ismail
  • Dick Gaetaniello
  • Dennon T Airey

Latest Activity on 451s

Ok thanx. So I found out that the hole was repairable with a plug/patch kit. I plugged it. However before that happened I put 2 or 3 cans of inflate a tire crap from a can. I intend to buy a new tire and mount it on the wheel. When its off I am goin…
2 hours ago
depends on how bad the damage is, the TPMS is in the valve stem, mounted in the wheel, if the hole is in the tread, a tire place can make a permanent patch or plug. if you drove a bit on the flat, you may have damaged your tire beyond repair. if it'…
3 hours ago
Mr Steve Jeffries added a discussion
Does anyone use a Smart waterproof cover.What are your experiences of using it.The genuine dealer accessory looks pretty cool.
4 hours ago
urban wheeler added a discussion
Ok so I have a flat. I loaned my smart car compressor to a buddy. I used a can of inflate and seal from the auto parts store. How does my tpms work? where is the sensor? does it need replacement with my tire? is it in the wheel well or in the tire?…
17 hours ago
urban wheeler added 2 photos to the album 'Urban wheeling'
17 hours ago
Steve Fockler added 5 photos
yesterday
Believe it or not, front tire wear can be improved by changing the rear springs! I have a car with new rear springs I originally put in for better handling and less body roll in the corners. before the spring change, I had similar wear issues with t…
on Friday
Oneoftheguyz added a discussion
Now Available for immediate delivery! Rear Performance Springs for Smart 451 3 GUYZ, Inc. is a manufacturing company just outside Portland, Oregon. We acquired two Smart 451s as commuter cars, and rapidly became enthusiasts. As a result, we felt…
on Friday

smartCar on Facebook/Twitter

facebook.com/smartCartwitter.com/smartCarRSS

smart Photos  |  smart Videos  |  smart Forum  |  smart Blogs  |  smart Events  |  smart Car Clubs

Badges  |  Bug Report  |  Terms of Service

Sign in to chat!
Disclaimer: This is a user generated "Web 2.0" community, smart GmbH, smart USA and smart Canada are not responsible for the maintenance or creation of this page.
All brand names and/or trademarks used are for reference only and are the property of their respective holders.